“Whenever we look into the face of an enemy, we see ourselves.”
Howard Thurman
Photo by Taylor Smith@taylor_smith
I want to deal with the issue of accountability. From my post last week, one could assume that I am not in favor of holding people accountable for their actions. The post was a reflection on Howard Thurman’s quote that basically says that seeing another person as an enemy is like holding a mirror up to ourselves. The negative things we see in them are often the negative things we don’t care to see in ourselves. The way I said it last week was, “Enemies are projections of what we don’t like in ourselves.”
But it would be a mistake to jump all the way from that deeper awareness to the assumption that we should then never hold people accountable. The argument could be made if what we don’t like in another person is really just a reflection of something in ourselves then what right do we have to judge or hold that person accountable.
That would be a wrong assumption! The process of acknowledging that the evil we see in others is just a projection of the capacity for evil in ourselves is not to let others off the hook. It is to simply come to the conclusion, “But for the grace of God go I.” In other words, is it possible that if you were in that person’s shoes you might have made the same choices? If you had been abused or victimized or neglected. If your parents had molded you and shaped you differently. If you had grown up on a different side of the tracks—either forcing you into poverty or shielding you from poverty.
The problem with making an enemy out of others is that it too easily erases their humanity and makes it easier to reject them, dismiss them, and even erase them from the world. When we realize that all of us have the capacity for evil, it opens the door to empathy and compassion for those who have fallen or been tempted by the devil in the wilderness.
My point is this. People do need to be held accountable. But labeling a person an enemy allows us to too easily justify punitive actions. And why not? They’re not really human, right? But once we see people as fellow humans on this complicated journey of life, once we even see them as brothers or sisters, it acts as pause button on our punitive actions. Are we punishing others just because their actions make us uncomfortable? Or are we holding people accountable because their actions, left unchecked, hurt others?
I don’t deny that people need to be held accountable. But we will only know whether we are projecting our own evil on others when we make the shift from seeing people as brothers or sisters, rather than enemies.
I believe there are no enemies in life. There are only brothers and sisters who have fallen from God’s good intentions for us.